The Tax Reform Bill and Devolution of Powers in Nigeria: A Path Towards Fiscal Federalism
The recently proposed Tax Reform Bill represents a significant turning moment for Nigeria, with implications that extend beyond revenue distribution to the foundational principles of federalism. While the mechanisms for revenue allocation within the bill have ignited discussions, the issues at stake are deeper and politically sensitive. A key point of contention raised by the bill is whether the Federal Government should primarily act as a revenue collector and distributor or focus on its essential constitutional responsibilities. The current system, marked by excessive centralisation, impedes economic growth and undermines the principles of fiscal federalism.
One of the most controversial aspects of the bill is its emphasis on Value Added Tax (VAT), which is fundamentally a tax on sales or consumption typically managed at the state level. The centralized control of consumption taxes is considered is an anomaly that limits the autonomy and fiscal capacity of state governments. This dependence on the Federal Government for revenue and subsidies is proving to be unsustainable, hindering innovation and restricting states from developing fiscal policies that align with their specific economic strengths and needs.
The potential for revenue generation at the sub-national level is often underestimated. The existing system tends to discourage initiative and accountability, leading to a culture of dependency. By adopting a more decentralized approach, it would be possible to unlock previously untapped revenue streams. For example, Plateau State has rich agricultural potential due to its rich arable land; but it is constrained by an overly centralized revenue system. Similarly, Spain’s success in the global olive oil market illustrates how states can specialize and generate significant revenue based on their unique resources. Additionally, Europe’s strong economies, many of which lack significant oil reserves, demonstrate that it is possible to thrive without relying heavily on a single resource.
Proposed Solutions: Embracing Fiscal Federalism
To unlock Nigeria’s vast economic potential and strengthen its federal structure, the following strategic recommendations are proposed:
- Decentralization of VAT: Abolish the current federally controlled Value Added Tax (VAT) system and delegate its collection and management to state governments. This change would empower states to design their own VAT policies that are tailored to their unique economic circumstances, thus invigorating local economies.
- Promoting State-Level Revenue Diversification: States should be encouraged to identify and cultivate their specific revenue sources. By investing in infrastructure, education, and skill development that are aligned with each state’s strengths, a more conducive environment for varied revenue streams can be created.
- Strengthening State Revenue Collection Mechanisms: Provide states with the capacity and resources to effectively collect taxes at the local level. This requires investing in training, technology, and anti-corruption measures. A reduction in reliance on federal handouts will incentivize more efficient and responsible fiscal management.
- Redefining the Federal Government’s Role: The Federal Government should concentrate on its core constitutional responsibilities, such as national security, defence, foreign policy, and regulation of interstate commerce. Revenue allocation should align with this redefined role, ensuring funding for essential functions.
- Establishing a Fairer Revenue Sharing Formula: Along with the transfer of VAT collection to states, it is crucial to develop a transparent, equitable, and predictable revenue-sharing formula. This formula should address disparities between states and guarantee adequate funding for essential national services, necessitating a comprehensive analysis of each state’s economic capacity and potential for revenue generation.
The Tax Reform Bill presents a great opportunity to restructure Nigeria’s federal system. By embracing fiscal federalism, Nigeria can unlock its vast economic potential, enhance good governance, and promote sustainable development. The path forward requires not just a redistribution of revenue, but a fundamental shift in fiscal philosophy and a commitment to empowering states to become financially independent and accountable. This will lead to a more equitable and prosperous nation.
Contributor
